Showing posts with label Society. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Society. Show all posts

Sunday, March 10, 2013

A smaller world is a lesser one...

When we took an auto to Alpha One mall yesterday, the auto driver did not agree to drop us at the mall, but a few hundred meters away from it, because he was supposed to take another route. (The mall is less than two kilometers from where I stay). We had no choice but to walk. And as I walked, I saw the families that lived on the pavement. Not that it was the first time I saw people living by the side of the road, especially since it is a rather common sight in Ahmedabad, but after a long long time I saw them so closely. People sleeping, camouflaged in the dust, kids playing with broken tree branches, women cooking on firewood.
And I realised that although I know for a fact that there are countless families that live by the side of roads, I hardly get to 'see' them anymore. I travel so much and so fast that I end up being concerned about just the destination (which in this case was the mall). And the speed of my journeys obscures everything that lies in the way. I look at people fleetingly. I recognise the phenomenon too and even reconnect it within my mind with what I have read, discussed and written about issues of development-induced homelessness. But then I do not retain it long enough. And once I reach the mall, I get lost in the brands and the visual merchandise and the lights.
I felt something similar when I was travelling in a passenger train from Gomoh to Gaya. Passenger trains are good eye-openers. For all those who refuse to come out of the bubble of development, need to travel by passenger trains for a reality check. When you take a car to travel a distance of a couple of hundred kilometers, you fail to observe certain things. The reason being the fact that amongst a few things that the governments nowadays do invest in, are good, wide roads.  These roads are more often than not widened and re-constructed after displacing the 'encroachers'. And you love speeding on these roads. Passenger trains, on the other hand, offer a rather different landscape both inside and outside. You stand for long hours in a crowded compartment and get ample time to observe and talk to people from different walks of life, people you would otherwise not encounter beyond them being your research subjects. Also, passenger trains tend to stop for exceedingly long periods in between stations and you are able to look into the houses and lives of people who live along the railway tracks.
It is the speed that makes all the difference in perspectives. As the speed increases, the world gets smaller and our perspectives get limited. We end up in a world that is sanitised of its 'unnecessary' complexities, a simpler world, a lesser world.

Saturday, January 12, 2013

'Buniyaad hilni chahiye'

What does it take to create an outrage of such a scale? What does it take to make the outrage prudent enough to ask deeper questions? What does it take to sustain the outrage? And what entails for it to subside?

I do not know the answers to these questions. Women have been subject to sexual violence since ages, but it took the rape and painful death of a 23 year old woman to make people leave there comfortable positions and get on to streets. Questions did not remain limited to stricter punishments for rape, people started probing into questions of how social constructs of gender have been unfair towards women and the third genders. I don't know how long the outrage would sustain. Will it subside once the rapists in the above case are hanged to death? Or will it lead to a rather populist decision of sanctioning death penalty for rape?

Either ways the problem remains. And as Dushyant Kumar wrote:
'आज ये दीवार पर्दों की तरह हिलने लगी 
शर्त लेकिन थी कि ये बुनियाद हिलनी चाहिए'
..the 'buniyaad', the bases of injustice remain intact.

I don't know whether to feel hopeful or hopeless by this outrage. I can think of it as a little something that happened as opposed to many 'nothings'. And as one of the guest speakers in a class I attended, remarked that she was surprised to see at least as many men protesting as there were women for the same cause... this definitely offers hope.
But, then once the outrage subsides then what. What do we do at our small, personal levels to keep the flame alight? Do we as mothers, sisters, daughters, friends, girlfriends, wives, resist the objectification of our identities, assert our identities as humans first? Do we as fathers, brothers, sons, friends, boyfriends, husbands, do the same?
The men who were outraged will certainly not become rapists or perpetrators of violence against women. But that addresses the problem at the surface. Everytime a father would stop and respect the fact that a daughter or a daughter-in-law is not a commodity for sale and purchase in the dowry market... Everytime a brother would stop considering his sister as his 'responsibility' or try to be her 'protector'... Everytime a son, a brother or a friend would think before casually using swear words that demean women.... Everytime a boyfriend would stop making casual remarks on the way his girlfriend looks or dresses up...Everytime a husband tries to adapt a portion of 'his' life, 'his' career, 'his' ambitions according to his partner's life and aspirations and not do so as a favour....we would move towards a change that is more fundamental and lasting.

Thursday, June 7, 2012

What is Craft to a Craftsman? Seeking answers from academia...

I am writing my Masters' dissertation on crafts. Notwithstanding the disillusionment with academic writing itself, I am encountering questions I would have otherwise posed quite easily and explored conveniently, thanks to my ever-judgemental self and a firm belief that I always innately knew the distinction between 'rights' and 'wrongs', howmuchsoever ambiguous they might seem on the surface. Sadly this is not what academia is about. So, in order to produce a piece of academic writing, I need to constantly remind myself that my understanding of 'rights' and 'wrongs' is perennially incomplete.
I understand that craft, as it was understood centuries ago, is not the same in the globalised, market driven world today. It is the different market actors that shape the dynamics of crafts today, actors who are powerful, to state it bluntly. It would be foolish to imagine crafts as a craftsman's eternal love, when the latter struggles on a daily basis to exist as a human.
No I do not harbour the illusion that the girl in Gottigere who dragged her polio-affected legs to the unit everyday and made 'Potli-buttons' to be stitched on Angarakha kurtas, had an undying love affair with her work. She earned Rs 1500 a month for her work and was constantly worried that if the unit closes down due to lack of sufficient orders, how will she pay her house rent share of Rs 800 and how will she buy her daily meal of 'anna-saaru'.
So did Coomaraswamy say in 1900s in his seminal works on Indian art and craft. He claimed that for the artisan in India, unlike his Western counterparts, art was not a means for individual expression. It was a legacy passed on from one generation to another, with very limited scope for individual creativity. And so does Soumhya Venkatesan's anthropological study of Pattamdai weavers in Tamil Nadu suggest. It asserts that artisans and craftsmen reproduce the more powerful outsiders' vision of aesthetics and creativity.
Nonetheless, if I was not writing an acdemic thesis, my intuition would tell me that no matter how diluted an individual's creativity gets in the wake of someone else's instructions, the very act of creating a work of art emanates a sense of fulfilment. My intuition would also tell me that the excitement that gleamed in the eyes of Madura, Lakshmi and many others when they created an embroidered motif out of some vague instructions, was not merely the satisfaction of a task well completed. Moreover, I would really want to believe that when the Pattamadai weaver in Soumhya's study writes a letter to the Chief minister of Tamil Nadu, seeking financial assistance for saving the 'dying craft', it is not just a means to encash the ongoing enthusiam about crafts.
But then is it not my own love for art and crafts that colours my perception of the artisan and her apparent love for the art? And is it not my romanticised view of the world around me that constantly seeks to overturn the balance of power in the favour of the underdog, in whatever small way possible.

I have been reading about capitalism and how capitalism constantly assimilates the contradictory voices in a particular context, in order to provide justifications for the insatiable capital accumulation and garner the required support (including the support of the dissenting voices). Now this assimilation or 'acculturation', as some call it, is so subtle and pervasive that after a point of time one cannot distinguish between what was purely motivated by capitalist intentions and what was against it.
I think it is a similar case with academia. While on one hand it thrives on reason and logic that is supposedly an antithesis of intuitive judgement, on the other hand it deploys intuition to arrive at amazing levels of ambiguity, by pitting one type of intuition against another. So, although I am not supposed to rely on intuitions to arrive at answers, academia invariably evokes them. And to add to the complexities, it evokes contradictory intuitions. Moreover, it blurs the line between pure logic and logic derived out of some or the other intuitive judgment. Or does such a line exist at all?

Saturday, December 25, 2010

if Binayak sen is guilty of sedition, so am I...

Every time i wish to shed the negativism that has crept inside my thinking, opinion, writings regarding the state of my country, every time i wish to celebrate hope, development, something sad, outright disgusting crops up. I am ashamed, not only of my country's castrated judiciary, corrupt politicians but also of the shameless apathy of my countrymen.
67 year old Dr. Binayak Sen, working in rural tribal areas of Chhatisgarh for his entire life, was sentenced to life imprisonment, charged guilty of sedition for his alleged connections with the Naxalite movement. If being sympathetic to the movement counts as sedition, I openly proclaim that I am sympathetic too. I might not agree to the means the movement has adopted, but that does not make me a lesser advocate of the goals the movement began with. If violence is what the Naxalites are condemned for, the injustice and violence on the part of Government and Police are no less condemnable. And if I need to choose, i would choose the Naxalites as the lesser evil of the two.

Thursday, December 2, 2010

'Gandhi was assassinated because he agreed to partition.'...'Chinese are shrewd and cruel people'...'Communism    means to oppose any development initiative'...'Nehru and his policies screwed India'...
At times, it occurs to me that we live in a world where everybody has an 'opinion' on everything, or rather i should say 'an expert opinion'

When I was a child, the first 'big' story book I came across was 'Ramcharitmanas'. When my grandfather handed it to me, he remarked that Goswami Tulsidas decided to pen this epic after 20 years of dedicated research and study of several great works of Hindu mythology. 'He took 20 years to start writing? Must be a really dumb fellow!' Thats what I felt at the age of eight....
I still do not consider 'Ramcharitmanas' a literary marvel, probably because of my antipathy towards Ram or because the style of writing does not appeal to me in the same way as do those of Kabir, Meera or Raheem, the other contemporaries of Tulsidas. However, I can never deny the fact that not only Ramcharitmanas is the most celebrated and revered epic poem of all times but also it revolutionized several facets of religion and literature by making both of them accessible to the masses. Moreover, it is undoubtedly the most loved work of literature in the country. 
Creating any such phenomenal work seeks countless years of perseverance,  seeks a thorough study of the subject and seeks humility to know more, understand better. 
"Swantah sukhaya Tulasi Raghunath Gatha" (I have sung this song of Lord Ram for self satisfaction). These words speak of humility borne out of knowledge and it is this humility where the poet's greatness lies.

The question is, Can we bring about an constant thirst for perfection that does not allow us to settle for something mediocre or shallow? Can we bring about the same urge for knowledge, an eye for every minute detail, a continuous pursuit for excellence, in everything we do, opine or ideate?

Monday, May 17, 2010

Identities we are 'born' with...

Continuing with the question of identities...
There are identities that get mutated at various levels, changed in varying situations, overcome by individuals and communities. The identities of caste, religion, sect, language, nationality and so on.

The awareness of one's religion gets numb in the struggle to survive and urge to succeed. It surfaces when we happen to attend (rarely) the ceremonies or festivals. It also surfaces stealthily when our friends following other religions celebrate theirs.
The identities of caste are more often than not belittled by the equations of power and money. However they do surface quite often and do so in a wide range of situations from arranging marriages to alluring voters.
Similarly identities of languages and nationalities often blend and blur their boundaries in this era of rapid globalization.

But, there are identities that do not conform to this pattern.
Identities that are overwhelming, identities that are 'inseparable'. The identities that speak most eloquently throughout the span of our existence and control the power dynamics governing our lives. Identities we find impossible to ignore, overcome, supersede.
One such example is the identity borne out of our sexuality. Do we ever ignore the fact that we are a male/female or a third gender? Least of all the latter. While the equations of male/female identities have been much discussed and debated, it is the third gender that calls for our attention due to our inability of overcoming the identity of sexuality. It is the third gender that bears the wrath of our being overwhelmed with our sexualities.
Do we ever wonder why are we not able to acknowledge them as humans? Perhaps because we hardly acknowledge ourselves as humans. The identities of being a male or a female homo sapien conveniently supersedes that.

Monday, November 16, 2009

Many attribute poor social indicators in India to her heavy reliance on the Soviet model for all these years. Partially true, however the subsequent non-reliance has yielded no better results either. Hence, there emerges a need for a more discreet and objective introspection, a certain level of conviction and a definitive plan of action.
The staggering economic growth of 3.5% per year shot upto 9% after the reforms were introduced and it was widely accepted that India took a bold, yet inevitable step of coming out of its cocoon. But, in the midst of all this hullabaloo almost everybody comfortably ignored the obscure, yet vital statistics that build a country's economy. These statistics, given the fancy name of 'social indicators', do not merely represent the jargon blabbered at human development conferences or crafted to vent out frustrations on coffee table conversations. These figures go a long way in creating a nation's destiny, laying foundation for the tomorrow we visualise for our future generations, if at all we do so.
When one talks of child nutrition or the problem of malnourishment, the premise does not remain limited to problems of acute poverty, non-availabilty of decent livelihood options or the lacunae in the public distribution sytem, in fact, it trickles down to the very soul of our socio-economic-cultural framework, evoking questions that are subtle, yet extremely vital. Questions of whether we can realise the new world of our dreams with a generation that was brought up with empty stomachs? Can we establish the foundation of a free thinking, free-spirited society with its youth harboring underdeveloped, poorly nourished bodies and minds?
Yet another set of disturbing questions....

Monday, November 9, 2009

Narmada movement and its tangible goals

They say it was ‘Moral victory’ for the struggle. Well, anything to salvage its wounded pride or perhaps its bruised soul, if there is left any. Moreover at this juncture there isn’t much left to lose, or to gain either. This struggle remains their only link to their long lost identity, which leaves them no option except continuing the same till an undefined milestone.
Does it sound too hopeless? Well, hopeless it is. Hopelessness inspite of the support the movement receives from different pockets all over the country. Whether it is the protest of 25 social activists outside the Madhya Pradesh Bhavan in Delhi on 5th of this month or a mass rally a week earlier in which thousands of displaced farmers gathered to protest against lathi charge and illegal arrests of NBA activists at the Khandwa Collectorate.
Support, protests, agitations induce more of them and the chain continue, but ironically leading nowhere. There is awareness and plentitude of empathy which to a great extent continues to fire the movement. But, at the end of the day, it seeks a different dimension. Solutions do not arrive while we follow the beaten path.
One does not ask to compromise with the fundamental goals of the movement, but one does seek inclusion of new ones, a certain reprioritizing and revamping of the achievables in the light of immediate concerns and changes in the national and international economic and political dynamics. One seeks victories that are more tangible in nature and eloquent enough to fuel the movement in the longer run, sustain it till the fundamental goals are realized. Such an inclusion need not necessarily be a diversification; rather it ought to emerge from the existing set of challenges. We merely need to expand our horizons and shed our ideological myopia. The needs of the displaced are multi-dimensional and ever-morphing to the changing socio-economic and political equations. Some of these needs which might seem the most unhindered and simpler to achieve, might yield dividends that are most eagerly sought for. This simplicity of theirs must not be the reason for lack of focus, for it would amount to one of the gravest mistakes on the part of the struggle.

Friday, October 2, 2009

Gandhi's India...I dont think I know it anymore!

Gandhi Jayanti remains one of the most significant days of the year to me. Not only does it remind me of one of the phenomena of all times that existed on this earth in the name of Mahatma Gandhi, but also it reaffirms within me the faith in the values he stood for, the values of truth, non-violence and love, the values whose presence in our hearts becomes more and more significant in this increasingly violent world.
However this year Gandhi Jayanti will remind me of the massacre in Khagaria, the massacre in which 100 gunmen, suspected to be Naxalites, mercilessly butchered 16 people, including 5 children. There are several questions that brutally follow this event. Are we actually becoming a violent society? Is armed struggle the only resort a common man finds in order to get noticed politically? Where does this road to violence and curbing violence with further massive forms of violence end?
The country has witnessed fresh attempts to curb naxal insurgencies in the recent times. An overall increase in armed forces to fight terror which includes additional troops, paramillitary forces and the state police force.
One can not help wondering if it would have been much effective to channelize these resources towards curbing the real causes behind this armed rebillion continuing for the past four decades, for this rebillion has been an outcome of an outright failure of government machinery, of social justice, of development. It is an aftermath of serious injustice incurred upon the poor.
There is a lot of mending to be done and it is not an easy task either. But the process has to begin somewhere.
I am reminded of the turmoil during partition. I am reminded of the continuous satyagraha Gandhi led against this violence, a satyagraha no less significant than the one he led against the Britishers. Only this time, to his great anguish, it were his own countrymen driven mad by the surge of hatred that swept away their entire sanity. Nevertheless, he continued his resistence without a hint of violence against this phase that symbolised one of the most bloodiest times of Indian History. And then it all ended, with Gandhi being shot dead by Nathuram Godse on January 30, 1948. They say that 'Mahatma Gandhi achieved in death what he had striven for in his last months of life. His murder ended forever the insensate communal killing of neighbour by neighbour in India's villages and cities.'
I wonder what it was that evoked such an extraordinary sense of remorse in the masses, that brought back their sanity and their ability to look beyond the blinding fury of hatred? Was it the death of a man who led them in a manner unprecedented in the world history and whom they failed so miserably by the incessant killing of their own brothers? Or was it the values of love, peace and non-violence so deeply engraved in their conscience that resurfaced without much effort when they saw this messiah of love succumbing to death?
Are we not the same people? Have we not inherited the same values? Is there something fundamentally different in the substance we are made of? The questions are disturbing.

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Clear Air Clear Water !!!

Have you ever tried pranayama? Oh no! I am not one of the Baba Ramdev followers (although he has become synonymous to it or vice versa!), neither am I asking you to be one. But, nevertheless, pranayama happens to be one of the wonderful forms of yoga which produces amazing results, increases your stamina, builds immunity, helps the body combat serious illnesses and (to cut short) keeps you healthy.

Well, I am not writing this article to reiterate the advantages of pranayama. What I intend to do is to recount my first experience with anulom-vilom. It is a type of pranayama in which you inhale from one of the nostrils, hold your breath for a while, let the air fill inside your lungs and then exhale from the other nostril. When I tried the above exercise, I could actually feel air entering each and every bronchiole of mine. Not only was it one of the most refreshing experiences I have had, but it also made me realize how valuable a gift is it to have a bountiful of clear air around you, and how often do we overlook its presence in our lives. Don’t we always take it for granted, the presence of clear air, clear water around us?

It is high time that we pause and ponder for a moment, consider a situation when we would cease to have these wonderful gifts of nature. Of course, the moment does not stand beckoning in the realms of the very next day. Neither does it in the near future. But, it is not too far either. But, obviously we remain so oblivious of the fact. Don’t we? After all we believe in living in the present! So we do not think for a second when we throw a polyethylene bag or a wrapper on the road, or drive alone in a car to the office instead of a car pool which seems so sub-standard.

We do not feel an iota of guilt while irreversibly poisoning the world, the world we are going to leave for our coming generations, a legacy we ought to be ashamed of. But, we need not have to answer anybody? Do we? We belong to a generation that lives in the present, lives life to its fullest. Is not it?

Monday, May 26, 2008

The Bihar I knew…

What did I know about Bihar, the place I was born at, the place where my roots lie? My recent visit to the interiors of Bihar was an eye-opener to someone like me, born in Bihar, but brought up in Jharkhand, culturally similar, yet very different from its parent state. Did I know the real Bihar, as it exists today? Or, was I harboring numerous illusions drifting me away from the reality? Did I simply know Biharis, living away from Bihar, representing a considerable chunk of Bihar, but certainly not the whole of it? The questions are disturbing enough.
Of course, I did not know that Bihar is considered amongst the fastest growing economies in 2006-2007, owing to its fast changing macro-environment. I did not know that Patna, the richest city of Bihar, boasts of a per capita income greater than the Indian average. I never cared to know that!
But, I certainly knew the Bihar which has been the birthplace of religions like Buddhism and Jainism, which first propagated the principle of non-violence so vehemently, a concept that has eluded the civilized world till now, the Bihar which marks the birthplace of Goddess Sita, who epitomizes womanhood for the Hindus of North India, and Guru Gobind Singh, the tenth Guru of Sikhs. It has been the land of Chandragupta Maurya and Ashok who gave this country one of its best periods of its social, economic and cultural history. It has given birth to the oldest and the best centers of education of Ancient India, in the name of Nalanda and Vikramshila universities. And, we all know the Bihar which gave this country some great national leaders, writers, scholars, academicians and is still producing the maximum number of IAS, IPS officers, IITians, Medical graduates, Software professionals and what not!
Everything seems a repetition after some time. Is not it? All this glorification and deification of a place which has been ranked amongst the poorest of all the states of India, a place where education is in its most dismal state, and corruption breaking its backbone in all sphere. A place where I found some of the finest people I ever met. At the same time a place where I saw some of the rudest and the most uncivilized lot living under the garb of an elite upper class and trying to be elite Middle class.
I cannot close my eyes towards its scintillating past which becomes almost haunting at times. I cannot remain silent at the mocking remarks of my fellow non-Biharis. It is too much for my proud soul to accept wordlessly. I can not join hands for Bihar-bashing either. I seek solutions; I seek answers from the Biharis, in and outside Bihar, who have remained neutral and just shamelessly neutral towards all this.